Home » Armenia » Currently Reading:

Indigenous Rights: Western Armenia Advocate Says Turkey Ddeal is “A Surrender of Historical Lands”

October 30, 2009 Armenia No Comments
Indigenous Rights: Western Armenia Advocate Says Turkey Ddeal is “A Surrender of Historical Lands”

representative of Armenians of Western Armenia says the protocols signed by Yerevan and Ankara earlier this month directly infringe upon the rights of Armenians of Western Armenia.

Under the protocols Armenia and Turkey establish diplomatic ties and undertake to develop bilateral relations in the future. The documents signed by the two countries’ foreign ministers on October 10 await ratification in both parliaments.

A member of the National Council of the Armenians of Western Armenia, chief representative of Western Armenia in a UN forum on indigenous peoples Armenak Abrahamyan says that the protocol “On Establishing Diplomatic Relations” commits Armenia to recognizing its existing border with Turkey, which, according to him, is an act of forgetting Western Armenia. According to Abrahamyan, as an indigenous people, Armenians are entitled to make a territorial claim under a corresponding UN resolution.

“This protocol means that Armenia gives up its historical Armenian lands. It means that the history of Armenia is completely changed and the rights of Armenians of Western Armenia do not exist and that there was no genocide,” says Abrahamyan.

Abrahamyan, who comes from a family of natives of Karin in modern Turkey, lives in France. He took an active part in the Karabakh war and says “many like me fought till the end for Karabakh.”

“I would never expect such an attitude from Armenia’s leadership. What happened now that they’ve started such a movement against us?” queries Abrahamyan.

The National Council of the Armenians of Western Armenia was set up in 2004 in Shushi, Karabakh, with the goal of uniting Western Armenians from all over the world. The Council has assemblies in different places of the world to where Western Armenians can apply for the protection of their rights.

Some political analysts, unlike Abrahamian and his supporters, think that in the case of the return of Western Armenian lands, currently populated by Kurds (15 million) to Armenia, Turkey will do great harm to Armenia.

Thus, head of the Chair of Political Science at the Yerevan State University Gagik Keryan thinks that Armenia should establish diplomatic ties and get the border opened first and only then think about presenting territorial claims.

“If Western Armenia is returned to Armenia, then Armenia will face the Kurdish issue. What will we, less then three million Armenians with our mentality of leaving for Los Angeles, do against 15 million Kurds?” says Keryan.

Abrahamyan, meanwhile, says that these territories should first be populated by Armenians and only then the border should be opened.

“We created our organization in order to prepare our people,” says Abrahamyan and adds that if ratified, the protocols will become legal documents and the only way to contest them will be to apply to court, which “requires much effort and guarantees no success.”

Abrahamyan is also critical of the provision of the protocols that envisage the establishment of an intergovernmental sub-commission on the so-called “historical dimension” of relations between Armenia and Turkey.

“Don’t we yet know our history? We don’t need Turks in order to know our history,” says Abrahamyan.

The leadership of Armenia and their political allies insist that the current rapprochement with Turkey is taking place without preconditions and does not compromise on any national issue, including the issue of Western Armenia and genocide.

Source: ArmeniaNow - Original Article

Related News:

  1. Charles Aznavour reminded Turkey about Armenia’s lands
  2. Will Gagik Tsarukian Buy Western Armenia?
  3. Armenia and Turkey Working on Creating Historical Commission, Says Clinton
  4. “The Liberated Territories Are Not Subject To Surrender”
  5. Western Prelacy of The Armenian Apostolic Church Sues The Getty Museum For Stolen Illuminated Manuscripts

Comment on this Article:







Spam Protection by WP-SpamFree

Apricot Stone: Eva Rivas in Eurovision 2010

-

AdvertisementAdvertisementAdvertisementAdvertisement

The Protocol

Full Text of The Armenian Turkish Protocol

Recent Comments

  • Jean Jaques bagrationi: Typical ungrateful Georgians. Everything Georgians have today, was because of th...
  • Jean Jaques bagrationi: Look, religious freedom is fine and dandy, I for one, belong to an Armenian Pro...
  • Pyuzant: Jean Jagues Bagratyuni, God bless you,one more thing not only protect our mother...
  • john papazian: Every time the Turks say "prove it" I get to thinking,thousands of photographs,r...
  • john papazian: Why doesn't Armenia annex Karabakh?...
  • john papazian: First time here and looks good. Getting any real stance or conviction from Washi...
  • jean jaques bagrationi: Azerbaijan was created by the British to make the siphoning of the oil found the...
  • jean jaques bagrationi: If and when the border is opened, we should keep our eyes open, looking for infi...
  • jean jaques bagratyuni: Why on earth Armenian soldiers are denied body armor. This is traechery on the p...
  • Jean Jaques Bagratyuni: I wished Azerbaijan just shut up for a few days. When a force of 900 Armenian ir...

Tag Cloud

Poll

Should the Armenian Parliament ratify the Armenian-Turkish protocol?

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...

Our Sponsors

Commentary

On The Principles Of Self-Determination And So-Called “Territorial Integrity” In Public International Law (The Case Of Nagorno-Karabakh)

June 22, 2010

On The Principles Of Self-Determination And So-Called “Territorial Integrity” In Public International Law (The Case Of Nagorno-Karabakh)

By: Ara Papian – Head, “Modus Vivendi” Center

We are not going to negotiate over the right of the people of Artsakh (Karabakh) to self-determination.

Serzh Sargsyan, President of the Republic of Armenia, 1 June 2010

 

It is for the people to determine the destiny of the territory and not the territory the destiny of the people.

Judge Hardy Dillard, International Court of Justice, 16 October 1975

 

Is ‘Reconciliation’ Compatible with Justice?

June 2, 2010

Is ‘Reconciliation’ Compatible with Justice?

By Lucine Kasbarian

On Wednesday May 12, at the Armenian Library and Museum of America (ALMA) in Watertown, Massachusetts, editors Emil Sanamyan of the Armenian Reporter and Khatchig Mouradian of theArmenian Weekly spoke about their recent trip to Turkey sponsored by TEPAV – a Turkish think tank that has recently been promoting Turkish-Armenian relations. TEPAV is funded by TOBB, the Union of Chambers and Commodity Exchanges of Turkey.

 ALMA Executive Director Mariam Stepanyan welcomed the audience after which moderator Marc Mamigonian, Academic Affairs Director of the National Association for Armenian Studies and Research (NAASR), opened by noting that there was no formal title for the evening’s program because the trip was not necessarily part of what would be termed “Turkish-Armenian reconciliation or relations.”

Davit of Sassoon is Undefeated or Once More on Foreign Language-Medium Schools in Armenia

June 2, 2010

Davit of Sassoon is Undefeated or Once More on Foreign Language-Medium Schools in Armenia

By Ara Papian – Head, “Modus Vivendi” Center

The changes proposed by the Government to the law on language has recently become subject to heated public debate. It is natural and good that society express many opinions. This implies that we are gradually surmounting the legacy of the not-too-distant past. It is unfortunate, however, that those in favour of the chan­ges to the law are not putting forth reasonable counter-arguments to the political, legal, economic, psychologi­cal and cultural facts presented by their opponents, but are instead simply warping the essence of the issue in attempting to present the case as a manifestation of xenophobia and advocacy for self-imposed isolationism.

An Investigative Report:The Woodrow Wilson Center Desecrates its Namesake’s Legacy and Violates its Congressional Mandate

May 20, 2010

An Investigative Report:The Woodrow Wilson Center Desecrates its Namesake’s Legacy and Violates its Congressional Mandate

By: David Boyajian

Is the Woodrow Wilson Center seeking to discredit the Treaty of Sèvres on its 90th anniversary by honoring Turkish Foreign Minister Ahmet Davutoglu?

Woodrow Wilson, the 28th American president, is looking down in horror at what the Woodrow Wilson International Center for Scholars (WWC; WilsonCenter.org) is doing in his name.

Most Americans are not aware of the DC-based organization, or that their taxes comprise one-third of its multi-million dollar annual budget.

The WWC was created by Congress in 1968 through the Woodrow Wilson Memorial Act to commemorate the late president’s “ideals and concerns” and memorialize “his accomplishments.”

The WWC has in several ways, however, violated its Congressional mandate.

LATEST DIASPORA NEWS

USAID Provides $50 Million To Armenian For Economic Development and Social Reform

August 6, 2010

At an official ceremony held in the Republic of Armenia Ministry of Economy on August 6, 2010, Minister of Economy Nerses Yeritsyan, US Ambassador to Armenia Marie L. Yovanovitch and USAID/Armenia Mission Director Jatinder Cheema signed two Assistance Agreements under which the US Government will provide up to $50 million to the Government of Armenia for the period of 2010-2013 in support of the country’s economic development and health and social services reform, according to a release issued by US Embassy in Armenia .

Armenian Bread Price Set For Further Rise

August 6, 2010

The price of bread in Armenia looked set on Friday to soar further following the Russian government’s decision to ban all grain exports because of a severe drought that has devastated crops across Russia.

The move, announced by Prime Minister Vladimir Putin on Thursday, pushed international prices of wheat to the highest level since the 2007-08 global food crisis. They jumped by more than 12 percent in European commodity markets.

The wholesale and retail prices rose just as drastically in Armenia where one 50-kilogram sack of flour cost between 9,500 and 10,000 ($27.4) on Friday. The rise did not immediately push up bread prices. They are nonetheless expected to be adjusted accordingly in the coming days.

Armenian National Committtee of America (ANCA) Disbelieves Matthew Bryza Will Stand in The Way of Aliyev’s March To War

August 6, 2010

ANCA Executive Director Aram Hamparian commented on recent statement by political observer David Petrosian, who was cited as saying, “soonest appointment of a new U.S. ambassador to Armenia, – be it Matthew Bryza or someone else, is important in restraining Azerbaijan’s ambitions.”

Aram Hamparian responded as follows, “Just to be clear, this is the same Mr. Bryza who was the primary U.S. adviser to the Georgian government of Mikheil Saakashvili as he stumbled into war with Russia; the same diplomat with controversial ties to top Azerbaijani leaders (Foreign Minister Elmar Mammedyarov served as a groomsman in his Istanbul wedding to Caspian energy expert/advocate Zeyno Baran), the same nominee backed by senior Azerbaijanis close to the Aliyev regime and by leaders of the Azerbaijani American community, and; the same U.S. official who has, for more than a decade, turned a blind eye to Azerbaijani threats, military aggression, and acts of cultural desecration.

I Believe You Will: Mammadyarov and Davutoglu Discussed Karabakh Conflict

August 6, 2010

Azerbaijani Foreign Minister Elmar Mammadyarov hopes that his Turkish counterpart Ahmet Davutoglu will take very useful initiatives in the settlement of the Nagorno Karabakh conflict, reports Azerbaijani news agency Trend.

“Turkey is highly respected in the international arena, and therefore I believe that Ahmet Davutoglu will take very useful initiatives in the Karabakh settlement”, Mammadyarov said at a joint press conference following a summit of Turkic-speaking countries.

The summit was held in Bodrum town in western Turkish province of Mugla on Thursday bringing together foreign ministers of Turkey, Azerbaijan, Kazakhstan and Kyrgyzstan.

US Secretary of State Extends Her Gratitude To The Cafesjian Center For The Arts in Armenia

August 6, 2010

The US Secretary of State Hillary Rodham Clinton in a letter to the Director of Administration and the Acting Executive Director of the Cafesjian Center for the Arts Vahagn Marabyan thanked the Center for hosting her meeting with Armenian civil society leaders.

“The center is a magnificent landmark and a wonderful symbol of Armenian- American cooperation. Our tour of the Cafesjian sculpture garden and the Chihuly gallery was one of the highlights of my visit to Yerevan”, the letter of Secretary Clinton said.

US Secretary of State Hillary Rodham Clinton visited the Cafesjian Center for the Arts on July 5th, 2010. In her honor, a glass sculpture by Sidney Hutter was placed on exhibit – similar to the one by the same artist, added to the White House Craft Collection in 1993. The sculpture, known as the “White House Vase”, is now in the William J. Clinton Presidential Library.

Featured Books